Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


TiVo versus Time-Warner DVR!

I’ve had TiVo since… at least before Lost premiered.

Even when times are tough, I’ve been reluctant to give it up since I love the usability and there are still so many things I recorded that I haven’t watched yet.

Recently I began having trouble getting certain channels and, long story short, ended up with a cable box/DVR from Time Warner.

Now I can use both again but, despite some advantages of having a cable-company DVR, I still prefer my TiVo.

Here’s how they compare.

1. Thumbs up/Thumbs down

TiVo: You use the “thumbs up” or “thumbs down” buttons to tell TiVo what you like or don’t like. The reason they’re there is that, unless you tell it otherwise, the TiVo will record things it thinks you might like. It’s a bit unnerving at first when it starts recording on its own but if your TiVo is full, it won’t do that. And you can always review the TiVo Suggestions list and let it know when it’s wrong.

TW: The DVR won’t record anything you don’t tell it to record, which is probably preferable. But I can’t tell you how much I miss those thumbs up and thumbs down buttons! Even if my TiVo is the only one who knows that Nancy Grace deserves three thumbs down while The Simpsons deserves three thumbs up, I’m addicted to the thumbs!

Thumbs up: For me, TiVo.

2. Guide

TiVo: Shows you what’s playing now

TW: Shows you what’s playing now and you also have the option of browsing by genre or channel name

Thumbs up: TW, although it’s not a feature I really use.

3. Setting up Favorite Channels

TiVo: With so many channels I don’t want to watch (or don’t even get), I like to set my guide to “favorites” and skip the rest. Do it once in TiVo and you’re set.

TW: For some reason, the TW DVR keeps reverting to All Channels and choosing Favorites again is completely non-intuitive: I had to Google the procedure.

Thumbs up: TiVo

4. Aspect ratio

TiVo: Each channel displays the same (apart from letterbox broadcasts).

TW: Each channel displays differently until you set the master default the way you want it to be. Very frustrating as you flip through channels until you figure out there’s a way to fix it.

Thumbs up: TiVo

5. Recording

TiVo: One-click recording: If you hit “record” twice, it’ll ask you if you want to continue the recording or stop. You can also set the recording to go later than the scheduled time, as shows often run late.

TW: It’s also one-click and has the ability to end a minute or two after the set time, but, weirdly, it’s not always easy to tell when the DVR is recording: Sometimes there’s a little red light and sometimes not.

I ended up recording the same show three times, something that wouldn’t be possible with TiVo because it would tell me I was already recording it. 

Thumbs up: TiVo

6. Watching your recordings

TiVo: Push the TiVo button, then select “Now Playing.”

TW: Push “List” on the remote – (more about the remotes later) but the recording often skips ahead, jumping over scenes or moments. I’ve never experienced this kind of glitch with the TiVo.

Thumbs up: TiVo

7. Fast-forwarding

TiVo: The fast-forwarding in TiVo is clearly superior: You can jump to 15-minute segments, a feature that doesn’t exist with the DVR.

TW: No segments and there doesn’t seem to be a way to go to the very end or very beginning of a recording and the fast-forwarding seems to take a lot longer than it does on the TiVo.

Thumbs up: TiVo

8. Netflix and Amazon

TiVo: TiVo has the advantage again here because it’s easy to set up your Netflix account and watch it on your TV. There’s some hang-ups with streaming but that can happen on your computer too. I also set up Amazon but it turns out that if you stream an Amazon show on your TiVo, it’s actually downloading, so you get charged even if you have Amazon Prime. Bottom line: You can’t stream Amazon content for free with a TiVo.

TW: You can’t access either with the TW DVR.

Thumbs up: TiVo

9. Wishlists

TiVo: You can set up recording wishlists for actors, directors, genres and keywords. It’s unique to TIVo, which is why it’s a registered trademark.

TW: As I understand it, the DVR doesn’t have the equivalent of creating an actor or director wishlist, although it does have the equivalent of a Season Pass (recording every episode of a series.)

Thumbs up: TiVo

10. Restarting shows that you’ve missed

TiVo: If you happen to be on the right channel and no more than 30 minutes have gone by, you can rewind.

TW: As the current “rescan your item” TimeWarner ads demonstrate, even if you miss the beginning of a show, you can go back and start it. This doesn’t always work for me, but it’s great when it does.

Thumbs up: TW

10. On Demand

TiVo: With just a cable card and no cable box, I was never able to access On Demand. And if you miss episodes of your favorite show, you have to have recorded it or wait until it re-airs.

TW: On Demand is available for free movies, premium movies and just about every channel. It’s easy to catch up with any TV series, although the number of episodes available varies. Downside: You can’t fast-forward through ads when watching a TV show via On Demand.

Thumbs up: TW

11. Remotes

TiVo: I like the design: The buttons are nicely spaced out and you never hit the wrong one by mistake. Recordings and recording options are accessed by hitting the big “TiVo” button at the top. One problem: I was never able to get it to recognize the code for my TV, so I can’t turn my TV on and off with it.

TW: Too many buttons! I’m still getting to know it, but my biggest peeve is that the PLAY button is right beneath the LIST button so I can’t count how many times I’ve paused a program, then accidentally went to my list of recordings when I just meant to hit PLAY.

Thumbs up: TiVo

12. Cost

TiVo: You have to buy the unit, then pay a $12.95 fee. Plus the cost of a cable card.

TW: You rent the unit per month, about $11 a month.

Thumbs up: TW

13. Random weirdness

TiVo: Channels are sometimes not available, even with a cable card and a tuning adapter.

TW: When I turn on my TV, most of the time, there’s audio but no video. I have to select the channel to get the video, which is annoying.

Thumbs up: TW

The Verdict

A cable-company DVR offers On Demand and restarting a show from the beginning and it’s cheaper, but at the end of the day, once you’ve had a TiVo, it’s really hard to give it up.

1 Comment

1 Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply


Forces of Geek is protected from liability under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and “Safe Harbor” provisions.

All posts are submitted by volunteer contributors who have agreed to our Code of Conduct.

FOG! will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement.

Please contact us for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content.


In many cases free copies of media and merchandise were provided in exchange for an unbiased and honest review. The opinions shared on Forces of Geek are those of the individual author.

You May Also Like


Paramount Home Entertainment has announced that Halo’s epic universe and cast of bold characters are back when season two of HALO, executive produced by...


REACHER IS BACK – and this time it’s personal. In the heart-pounding second season of REACHER, when members of Reacher’s (Alan Ritchson) old military...


Captain Burnham and the crew of the U.S.S. Discovery return when STAR TREK: DISCOVERY THE FINAL SEASON arrives with even more “incredible action sequences...


From Creator/Showrunner/Executive Producer Jeb Stuart (The Fugitive, Die Hard), Warner Bros. Discovery Home Entertainment brings you the next chapter in the Vikings franchise, with...